Who is the greatest QB in Imperial history

[Vic Carucci]

Who is the greatest QB in Imperial history

[sovstar]

Nigel Booker. '04 Divisional Round...

[Vic Carucci]

Nigel Booker. '04 Divisional Round...

Instant classic. Greatest game ever, with this year's Imperial Bowl a close 2nd

[Suicane]

With no option for McMurray I'd have to cast my vote for Fingers.

[sovstar]

With no option for McMurray I'd have to cast my vote for Fingers.

He didn't ask who the biggest disappointment at QB or who the best QB with a career QB rating in the 70's was.

[Suicane]

You are sauccccy.

[Cringer]

I say Booker because the fact that he plays all the time breaks the tie breaker for me between him and Cartagena. Of course I may hold Cartagena to a slighlty high level then some because he likes to beat my team.

Given being on this list is a bit of a stretch to me. Yeah we went far last in '05, but it wasn't because he was great or anything. I would say Virgil Sepulveda is a bigger play maker and clutch QB.

[Jave]

Once again I argue, if you want to hold the title of Greatest anything, you must earn that in the playoffs. While I think Booker is a great QB, untill the Stallions can get deep in the playoffs, my vote goes for Cartagena.

[MrBigglesworth]

Once again I argue, if you want to hold the title of Greatest anything, you must earn that in the playoffs. While I think Booker is a great QB, untill the Stallions can get deep in the playoffs, my vote goes for Cartagena.

Booker beat Cartegena the last time they played in the playoffs.

[Kobeck]

Mules refuse to participate in such a biased anti-Willoughby poll

[Jave]

Booker beat Cartegena the last time they played in the playoffs.

We are talking, best of all time right? So ONE year, a guy beat another guys team. Ok, and Joe Montana didn't win the Superbowl EVERY year, but I think most would agree he could be considered the best QB of all time. You see where I am going? Year in and year out, Columbia is right there in the playoffs. SLC had a rough year, but since the poll was put out today, JC gets the edge.

[Warhammer]

I give the nod to Sanders. What that guy has done to the AC East for four years is just sick. Not to mention that whenever WVA has needed a spark, he has provided it. In several of the HAR-WVA games he has been the difference. I know he has ripped the heart out of NFK and BOS a few times to.

The only thing he hasn't done is deliver in the playoffs.

My #2 guy is Lozier. What he has done the last two years with very average receivers is impressive.

#3 is Booker, that guy has been a flat out stud.

The reason why I don't have Booker and Cartagena higher is they have been throwing the ball to much more talented receivers than either Sanders or Lozier. Additionally, Cartagena tends to get banged up which lowers his grade some.

[VitoStallion]

Once again I argue, if you want to hold the title of Greatest anything, you must earn that in the playoffs. While I think Booker is a great QB, untill the Stallions can get deep in the playoffs, my vote goes for Cartagena.

THIS IS WHY!!!

You just got your punk ass to the playoffs USING JEFF'S ADVICE. Your QB has the best WRs in the game to throw to AND he still manages to fuck games up. I can name 5 QB's I'd take OVER [Peyton] Hamilton. Easy to be GREAT when your WRs are elites.

Do you really think JC, Deuce, Finger, or the Colonel wouldn't embarass Hamilton's stats with the same receiving corps?

[VitoStallion]

I voted for Sanders by the way. So many wins and a subpar WR corps, yet he made it happen over and over again.

[Jave]

I can name 5 QB's I'd take OVER [Peyton] Hamilton. Easy to be GREAT when your WRs are elites.

Hamilton handed you, and your punk ass QB Booker, your ass 3 times this year. You had 3 chances, and you got owned every time. I will pick Hamilton, thank you.