| Team | GM | Actual Pick | Vancouver Pick | Vegas Pick | Tijuana Pick | Madison Pick | |
| 1 - 1 (1) | Montreal | superman66 | QB Cristian Godfrey | QB Cristian Godfrey | QB Patrick Kempthorne | QB Patrick Kempthorne | QB Cristian Godfrey |
| 1 - 2 (2) | Pittsburgh | loligag | WR Rico Serbicki | WR Rico Serbicki | QB Cristian Godfrey | QB Cristian Godfrey | WR Rico Serbicki |
| 1 - 3 (3) | Kansas City | jzicc | QB Patrick Kempthorne | QB Patrick Kempthorne | WR Rico Serbicki | WR Rico Serbicki | QB Patrick Kempthorne |
| 1 - 4 (4) | Miami | FedFan91 | RB Vincent Robertson | WR Lester King | WR Maxwell Peacock | RB Vincent Robertson | WR Maxwell Peacock |
| 1 - 5 (5) | State College | CoyoteVice | S Cory Hanrahan | RB Vincent Robertson | RB Vincent Robertson | S Cory Hanrahan | WR Lester King |
| 1 - 6 (6) | Raleigh | wayt34 | WR Lester King | WR Maxwell Peacock | S Cory Hanrahan | CB Isaiah "Sly" Witt | RB Vincent Robertson |
| 1 - 7 (7) | London | Slimmikey | CB Isaiah Witt | S Cory Hanrahan | CB Isaiah Witt | WR Maxwell "NBC" Peacock | S Cory Hanrahan |
| 1 - 8 (8) | Orlando | FrankieStarz | CB Riddick Hogans | TE Sebastian "Chubby" Chubb | CB Riddick Hogans | TE Sebastian "Chubby" Chubb | CB Isaiah Witt |
| 1 - 9 (9) | Hartford | roadhouse_band | WR Maxwell Peacock | CB Riddick Hogans | WR Lester King | CB Riddick Hogans | RB R.J. Offord |
| 1 - 10 (10) | Colorado | Aaron K | DE Mitch Starkey | CB Isaiah "Sly" Witt | TE Peter Gardner | WR Lester King | DE Mitch Starkey |
| 1 - 11 (11) | McAllen | Southpaw | TE Peter Gardner | WR Cornelius Blair | TE Sebastian Chubb | TE Peter Gardner | TE Sebastian Chubb |
| 1 - 12 (12) | Houston | Nemesis | WR Emmaneul Sprehe | TE Peter Gardner | RB Craig Claybrooks | DE Mitch "Mularkey" Starkey | CB Riddick Hogans |
| 1 - 13 (13) | Norfolk | iceman99 | TE Sebastian Chubb | RB RJ Offord | TE Mickey Hoover "Dam" | TE Mickey "Herbert" Hoover | TE Peter Gardner |
| 1 - 14 (14) | Salt Lake City | Nooby | RB RJ Offord | DE Mitch Starkey | DE Mitch Starkey | DE Donny James | DE Donny James |
| 1 - 15 (15) | Madison | Tuson | WR Cornelius Blair | WR Emmaneul Sprehe | WR Cornelius Blair | LB Rick Grant | WR Emmaneul Sprehe |
| 1 - 16 (16) | Los Angeles * | NOT JIM GINDIN | RB Shane Breese | RB Shane Breese | RB Shane Breese | RB Shane "A Cool" Breese | DT Noah Hill |
| 1 - 17 (17) | State College | CoyoteVice | LB Stephen Brovins | DE Donny James | WR Emmanuel Sprehe | DT Noah Hill | WR Cornelius Blair |
| 1 - 18 (18) | San Antonio | BGBob | CB Alphonso Lynn | RT Abraham Monroe | RT Abraham Monroe | LB Gino Fredrickson | LB Gino Fredickson |
| 1 - 19 (19) | Boston | krolikzaez | WR Isaac Sewell | DT Noah Hill | LT Erick Mansour | T Erick Mansour | LT Abraham Monroe |
| 1 - 20 (20) | Dakota | Clown | TE Jerome Downs | LT Harrison Parker | RB RJ Offord | RB Craig Claybrooks | RB Craig Claybrooks |
| 1 - 21 (21) | Alaska | Mellman | DE Donny James | WR Isaac Sewell | WR Isaac Sewell | WR Emmanuel "Sphere" Sprehe | CB Corbin Okeafor |
| 1 - 22 (22) | Portland | jmooreone | OLB Rick Grant | OLB Rick Grant | OLB Rick Grant | C Daryl Boyer | S Calvin Gaines |
| 1 - 23 (23) | West Virginia | fuzzyafroninja | DT Malik Theophilakos | RB Craig Claybrooks | CB Roderick Tubbs | DT Marty Collier | DT Marty Collier |
| 1 - 24 (24) | Georgia | Tony | T Abraham Monroe | ILB Gino Fredrickson | ILB Gino Fredrickson | C Ellis Simms | LB Rick Grant |
| 1 - 25 (25) | Horsetooth * | NOT JIM GINDIN | DT Noah Hill | LB Kai Martin | DT Noah Hill | LB Kai Martin | RB Shane Breese |
| 1 - 26 (26) | Calgary | Boots | RB Craig Claybrooks | CB Alphonso Lynn | CB Corbin Okeafor | LB Stephen Brovins | LT Harrison Parker |
| 1 - 27 (27) | Iowa City | Lannister | LB Gino Fredrickson | TE Zach Carlson | RB Brett Van Anden | S Calvin Gaines | TE Jerome Downs |
| 1 - 28 (28) | Las Vegas | Sabean | RB Brett Van Anden | CB Rich Denney | CB Rich Denney | G Albert Kozak | DT Calvin Lowe |
| 1 - 29 (29) | Murfreesboro | jamesumd | CB Corbin Okeafor | C Ellis Sims | C Darryl Boyer | CB Alphonso Lynn | RB Brett Van Anden |
| 1 - 30 (30) | Pittsburgh | loligag | TE Mickey Hoover | G Albert Kozak | LT Harrison Parker | WR Cornelius Blair | WR Isaac Sewell |
| 1 - 31 (31) | Columbia | Jeremy | CB Roderick Tubbs | CB Drake Horner | CB Alphonso Lynn | TE Howard Johnstone | C Daryl Boyer |
| 1 - 32 (32) | Tijuana | joe the commissioner | FB Gregory Buckey | FB Gregory Buckey | DE Donny James | FB Gregory Buckey | S Devin Hallows |
| correct picks: | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 |
How did we do? Believe it or not this was fairly successful in terms of correct picks for us. Did we get your position right but wrong player? Way off? Would you have taken our choice but they were off the board?
Comment